Queerness is often described as a state of being, or a set of identities, but it can also be understood as a way of thinking about the world that emphasizes openness and flexibility. This perspective suggests that queerness is less concerned with fixed definitions of selfhood or identity, and more focused on creating new possibilities for relating to others and exploring one's own desires and fantasies. In this sense, queerness might be seen as inherently post-metaphysical - a way of challenging traditional assumptions about what it means to exist in the world.
Some critics have argued that queerness has its roots in metaphysics, particularly in the work of thinkers like Michel Foucault who explored the ways in which power structures shape our understanding of sex and sexuality. For these scholars, queerness is a form of resistance against dominant modes of thought, rather than an ethic of openness. They argue that queerness depends on a stable conception of identity, which allows individuals to challenge societal norms and assert their right to live authentically.
While both of these approaches have merit, it's important to recognize that they are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Queerness may indeed be a form of resistance against oppressive systems of power, while still embracing an ethics of openness and flexibility. It's possible to imagine a world where we move beyond rigid ideas of identity and explore new forms of connection without losing sight of the importance of social justice and political action.
The idea that queerness is inherently post-metaphysical can lead to misunderstandings about how queer communities relate to other identities and movements.
If queerness is understood as simply a matter of personal choice or lifestyle, it can erase the experiences of those who face systemic discrimination based on race, gender, class, disability, or other factors. Instead, it's crucial to recognize that queerness is part of broader struggles for liberation, and that solidarity among marginalized groups is essential for achieving true freedom and equality.
In sum, queerness is a complex concept with many meanings and interpretations. While some see it as purely metaphysical, others view it as inherently post-metaphysical and focused on creating new possibilities for relating to others. Regardless of one's perspective, it's important to acknowledge the importance of intersectionality and solidarity in any discussion of queerness.
Is queerness inherently post-metaphysical, existing as an ethics of openness rather than a doctrine of being?
Queer theory has been defined as "a critical framework for thinking about sexuality that challenges the dominant normative and binary ways of constructing identity" (Kitzinger 1998). The term 'queer' is often used interchangeably with the terms 'non-normative', 'deviant', 'different', and 'alternative'.