Identity is more than just a collection of traits that define an individual; it is also a social construction. While some aspects of identity can be fixed, others are fluid and changeable depending on context. This raises the question: Can authenticity be achieved when identity is always mediated, relational, and evolving?
The answer to this question is complicated. Authenticity involves being true to oneself, but it is impossible to achieve if one's self is constantly changing. Identity is formed through interactions with others, and these interactions are often influenced by external factors such as cultural norms, societal expectations, and personal experiences. These factors can shape how we see ourselves and what we value, which may lead us down different paths from those we would have taken otherwise.
One way to approach the issue of authenticity is to consider the concept of "authentic identity," whereby individuals try to align their actions with their core values despite the influence of outside forces. This requires introspection and self-reflection, as well as active engagement with their communities and environments.
Even when trying to live authentically, people may struggle to balance their own desires against the needs of those around them.
Someone who wants to dress in a particular way may find themselves pressured into conforming to societal norms or risking rejection by peers.
Another viewpoint is that authenticity is not possible because identities are inherently fluid and ever-changing. People may try to present a consistent image of themselves to the world, but this image will never perfectly match up with reality. Instead, they should embrace the idea of multiple identities and understand that their sense of self is shaped by an array of influences. This doesn't mean abandoning all attempts at authenticity; rather, it means recognizing that our identities are always in flux and accepting that there may be conflicting aspects within us.
The most accurate answer seems to be that both views hold truth: authenticity is possible in some situations but not all.
Each person must decide for themselves what constitutes genuineness and how much they value it. Some may prioritize consistency and stability over authenticity, while others may place more emphasis on flexibility and growth.
Is authenticity possible in contexts where identity is always mediated, relational, and evolving?
No, authenticity is not possible in contexts where identity is always mediated, relational, and evolving because these factors can change and shape our identity over time. Our identity may shift based on different social interactions, cultural norms, personal experiences, and other external influences that impact how we view ourselves and others. In addition, the concept of authenticity is often tied to a static or fixed notion of self, which contradicts the idea of an ever-changing and dynamic identity.