The issue of whether the audience's discomfort is an indication of moral progress or cultural resistance has been debated for centuries. Many argue that it can be seen as a positive sign that people are becoming more open-minded about different forms of expression, while others believe that it indicates a lack of acceptance of diverse perspectives.
This debate is often oversimplified and misleading. In reality, both sides have valid arguments, but they need to consider the nuances involved in order to come up with a fair assessment.
One argument in favor of moral progress is that audiences tend to react negatively to unfamiliar experiences because they do not know how to process them yet.
When new art forms emerge, such as modern dance, jazz music, or abstract painting, many people find them challenging and even disturbing. Nevertheless, once these genres gain popularity, the public tends to become more accustomed to them and may start appreciating their unique qualities. This suggests that discomfort can lead to growth and learning, which eventually leads to moral progress.
Some scholars argue that cultural resistance is behind audiences' discomfort. They claim that certain groups or individuals intentionally avoid or reject new ideas or expressions that challenge traditional values.
When the LGBTQ+ community became more visible in the media, there was widespread criticism from conservative sectors who considered it morally wrong and immoral. The same applies to representations of non-conformist sexuality in movies and television shows. Some people fear change and would rather stick to what they know than embrace diversity. Therefore, discomfort could be an indication of cultural resistance rather than moral progress.
Both sides have merit, but neither should be taken at face value. Moral progress does not always equal acceptance and openness; instead, it requires understanding and critical thinking about different perspectives. Cultural resistance can also be driven by genuine concerns for values and principles that are important to certain individuals or communities. It is crucial to approach this issue with respect and nuance to reach a well-informed conclusion.
Does the audience's discomfort signify moral progress or cultural resistance?
Discomfort is often associated with feelings of unease, disquietude, and anxiety. It can be triggered by various factors such as changes in surroundings, physical sensations, or unfamiliar situations. When it comes to issues related to gender identity, sexual orientation, and expression, this feeling can be heightened due to social stigma, prejudice, and discrimination that individuals may encounter.