Many histories of LGBTQ+ people have been written from a cisgender heterosexual viewpoint, ignoring their experiences and making them seem like deviants who were immoral. These narratives have shaped moral attitudes towards LGBTQ+ individuals, causing them to feel shame and fear about themselves.
These views are incorrect because all humans are equal and should be treated fairly regardless of their gender identity or sexual orientation. Revising historical accounts is important for creating an ethical society that accepts everyone equally.
The historical narrative can influence how society sees members of the LGBTQ+ community. When stories focus on their deviant behaviors, it creates stereotypes that make them seem unworthy of respect and dignity. This attitude has led to physical violence against them, denial of their rights, and discrimination in employment and education. To create a more inclusive world, historical narratives must shift away from condemning people based on their identities to understanding them as human beings with unique needs and desires. Historical writing should showcase their achievements rather than emphasize their flaws or shortcomings.
To rewrite history ethically, researchers need to gather accurate information without bias. They must use primary sources from reputable scholars who have studied the subject thoroughly. Then, they must present this data objectively while highlighting its significance and impact. Writers should also avoid sensationalizing events or portraying them as taboo topics. Instead, they must provide nuanced insights into societal dynamics that may have influenced decisions made by the characters involved.
Writers should consider multiple perspectives when describing situations and include diverse voices in their writings.
Historians should aim to write ethically when discussing minority groups like the LGBTQ+ community. By doing so, we can ensure that future generations understand these individuals as complex human beings deserving of our love and support instead of shaming them for being different.
How do historical narratives shape moral attitudes toward LGBT existence, and how can they be ethically rewritten?
Research suggests that historical narratives often contribute to negative attitudes towards LGBT individuals as they tend to portray homosexuality as sinful or immoral, thus promoting stigma and discrimination (Fine & Asch 2016; Swaab et al. 2017).