The recurring trope of "trans tragedy" in film reflects societal discomfort with transformation by exploring the experiences and struggles of trans individuals through narratives that often end in death or mental illness. This reinforces society's belief that being trans is a dangerous, shameful, and unacceptable way to exist.
In films like Boys Don't Cry and Transamerica, transgender characters are portrayed as tragic figures who ultimately meet their demise due to discrimination and misunderstanding. In these stories, the protagonists are often victimized and marginalized for their gender identity, leading them down a path of violence and self-destruction. The trope perpetuates the idea that being trans is inherently unsafe and causes suffering. It also suggests that trans people need to conform to cisnormative ideals to be accepted and loved.
This type of storytelling contributes to societal stigma against trans people by creating an atmosphere of fear and distrust around them. It reinforces the idea that they are abnormal and should not exist at all. This attitude can lead to increased discrimination and violence against trans individuals, further exacerbating the problem.
Some films such as A Fantastic Woman and Tangerine challenge traditional trans tropes by depicting trans characters as resilient and strong, overcoming obstacles and finding joy in life. These stories show that trans individuals can thrive despite the challenges they face, and that there are many different ways to live a fulfilling life.
Even these more positive representations still reflect a lack of understanding about what it means to be trans. They tend to focus on the trans character's journey towards acceptance and validation from others, rather than exploring their own internal experiences and desires. As a result, they continue to contribute to the notion that being trans is not a natural or valid part of human existence.
The recurring trope of "trans tragedy" in film demonstrates society's discomfort with transformation and its efforts to police gender identities. By presenting trans individuals as tragic figures who ultimately fail, it reinforces the belief that being trans is dangerous and shameful.
Progressive films like A Fantastic Woman and Tangerine offer hope for greater representation and understanding of this marginalized community.
What does the recurring trope of “trans tragedy” in film say about societal discomfort with transformation?
The trope of "trans tragedy" in film speaks volumes about society's ambivalence toward transgender identity. While there are many stories that celebrate trans people and their journeys, films like "Boy Erased," "A Fantastic Woman," and "Dallas Buyer's Club" often portray trans individuals as tragic victims who face rejection from family members, employers, friends, and even strangers due to their gender transition.