Naughty Neighbors was released in a time when online pornography was just starting to become widely accessible, and it catered to viewers who preferred their adult content to be more personalized and less formulaic than what they could find elsewhere. Instead of featuring professional models and overly staged scenarios, Naughty Neighbors focused on real people next door - neighbors, coworkers, friends of friends - who agreed to share their sexy stories and erotic adventures for money. These subjects were often everyday people without professional modeling experience, which gave the magazine an air of authenticity that set it apart from its competitors. The magazine also featured nontraditional body types and fetishes that mainstream publications rarely covered. For example, one issue featured a woman with alopecia sharing her story about how she navigated dating while bald, while another showcased a group of sex workers discussing their experiences in the industry.
The original editorial team behind Naughty Neighbors included several well-known names in the adult entertainment industry, including founder John Stagliano and writer Mike Sullivan. However, the magazine's success led to some controversy among those involved. Some crew members accused Stagliano of exploiting them financially and not properly compensating them for their work. This led to a lawsuit against him by some of his former employees, which ended in settlements but did not stop the publication from continuing. Despite these issues, the magazine continued to release new editions until 2014, when it ceased production due to declining sales and changes in the pornography industry. While Naughty Neighbors may no longer be published, its impact can still be felt today through its influence on other magazines and online content. Its focus on authenticity and diversity helped pave the way for more inclusive representation in adult media, and its legacy continues to inspire new creators looking to break into the industry.