Although Naughty Neighbors primarily featured amateurs, it wasn't uncommon to see known models from Score, Voluptuous, or XL Girls making special appearances under slightly altered personasdressed down and styled to look more "everyday." This crossover allowed Score Group to recycle talent in new settings and also gave readers the thrill of seeing familiar faces in more casual, playful scenarios. In addition to the obvious benefits of cross-promotion and fan satisfaction, this approach helped keep the material fresh and interesting for both the producers and viewers. For instance, Chelsea Charms starred as "Tiffany" in Naughty Neighbors 12. Her character was a friendly young woman who offered to help with yard work but ended up seduced into a wild threesome instead. The scene was shot at the home of one of the regular cast members, who played her boyfriend. Likewise, Gina West portrayed a neighbor named "Beth" who got caught masturbating while sunbathing nude by her hot husband. Other examples include Tara Lynn Foxx as "Alice," an exotic dancer who performed lap dances for a couple of construction workers; Juelz Ventura as "Melanie," a delivery girl who entertained two horny husbands in exchange for her services; and Linsey Dawn McKenzie as "Jennifer," a sultry maid who cleaned up after the boys before getting dirty herself.
This crossover strategy could be seen as a win-win situation. Fans enjoyed recognizing their favorite models in different roles and contexts, and the performers were able to branch out beyond their usual stereotypes while still showing off their best assets. It was a clever way to mix things up without sacrificing quality or breaking budgetary constraints. However, some critics argued that this approach risked confusing audiences or diminishing the credibility of the talent involved. For example, if viewers knew a model had already appeared in another title, it might take away from the illusion of spontaneity or genuine lustiness on screen. Still, Naughty Neighbors continued to use crossovers until its discontinuation in 2014, providing fans with endless fantasies and memories of their favorite adult stars.