One of the main ways that the narrative of "becoming" obscures the reality of simply "being" for trans individuals is through the focus on the transition process. Trans individuals are often portrayed as going through a journey of becoming their true self, where they must undergo physical and emotional changes to align with their gender identity.
This narrative fails to acknowledge that being transgender is more than just a physical transformation - it's about living authentically and embracing one's identity regardless of physical appearance. This emphasis on transition also can lead to transphobia from cisgender people who view the transition process as something unusual or abnormal. Instead, trans individuals should be able to live openly and freely without feeling like they need to justify their existence or explain themselves.
Another way that the narrative of "becoming" obscures the reality of simply "being" is through the idea that trans individuals have achieved some kind of final destination once they have fully transitioned. This notion reinforces the idea that there is an ideal gender binary, where someone either has to fit into one category or another. It ignores the fact that many trans individuals may feel comfortable in multiple identities and express themselves in different ways at different times. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to transition, and each individual's path should be respected and accepted.
The narrative of "becoming" also obscures the reality of simply "being" by focusing on gender stereotypes and expectations. It suggests that trans individuals must conform to traditional notions of masculinity or femininity in order to be considered valid, which limits their ability to explore and express their full range of interests, passions, and desires.
The pressure to perform gender norms can cause trans individuals to feel isolated and alone, especially if they do not fit neatly into any particular box. Trans individuals should be allowed to express themselves in whatever way feels authentic and true to them, without fear of judgment or criticism.
The narrative of "becoming" obscures the reality of simply "being" by emphasizing physical changes over emotional ones. While it's important for trans individuals to be able to present themselves as their true selves physically, it's equally important to recognize the emotional challenges they face, such as depression, anxiety, and self-doubt. Mental health support should be readily available to all trans individuals, regardless of whether or not they choose to undergo physical transition.
The narrative of "becoming" is a limited and harmful viewpoint that fails to acknowledge the complexity and diversity of trans experience. By embracing the idea of simply being transgender, we can create a more inclusive and accepting society where everyone has the freedom to express themselves authentically and openly.
How does the narrative of “becoming” obscure the reality of simply “being” for trans individuals?
The narrative of "becoming" obscures the reality of "being" for trans individuals by suggesting that there is a distinct journey from one identity to another, implying that trans people are not complete until they reach their desired gender expression. This can lead to feelings of shame, guilt, and failure when transitioning isn't easy or possible.