Mainstream news outlets have been known to shape public opinion through their coverage of social issues such as gender nonconformity. In recent years, there has been an increase in the representation of individuals who identify outside of traditional binary genders in media portrayals.
It is essential to understand how these outlets frame these stories and what impact this can have on society at large. This article will examine some examples of gender nonconforming narratives from mainstream news outlets and explore the ways in which they construct or deconstruct them.
One example of gender nonconforming narrative is the story of Chaz Bono's transition from female to male. This was covered extensively in the media, and it was reported that he underwent surgery to become physically male while also expressing himself as masculine. The New York Times, for instance, featured a front-page story about his decision to "deal with" being transgender rather than "cure" it. Some critics argue that this framing perpetuates harmful stereotypes about trans people, suggesting that they need medical intervention to be seen as normal. Other sources have taken a different approach, emphasizing the individuality of each person's journey and highlighting their unique experiences.
The Washington Post published a feature on Jesse Money, who identifies as both male and female, and explored her personal choices regarding surgical procedures. The article acknowledged the complexity of identity and the importance of allowing individuals to make their own decisions without judgment.
Another area where media outlets have explored gender nonconformity is within the context of sports. Caster Semenya, an athlete born with hyperandrogenism, has faced scrutiny over her physical appearance, which many believe gives her an unfair advantage in competitions. Her case made international headlines and sparked discussions about fairness and equality. Some reports have focused on the controversy surrounding her participation in women's events, while others have chosen to focus on her athletic achievements or the impact of hormone therapy on her body. These narratives reveal how mainstream news outlets can shape perceptions of gender and create binary categories that exclude certain individuals from recognition.
Some outlets have used humor to explore gender nonconformity, such as a segment on Saturday Night Live featuring comedian Michael Che's perspective on his pronouns. This piece was designed to challenge societal norms and challenge viewers to think critically about assumptions about gender identity. It also demonstrated that gender nonconformity can be funny and not just serious. By presenting these stories in a variety of ways, mainstream news outlets can help break down stereotypes and misconceptions, allowing for greater acceptance and understanding of all genders.
It is clear that mainstream news outlets play a significant role in shaping public opinion regarding gender nonconformity. They can construct or deconstruct narratives by emphasizing certain aspects of individuals' journeys and ignoring others. While some coverage may reinforce harmful stereotypes, others can challenge societal norms and promote inclusivity. It is essential to continue to hold media outlets accountable for their reporting and ensure that all voices are heard equally in this important conversation.
How do mainstream news outlets construct or deconstruct narratives about gender nonconformity?
News outlets tend to construct or deconstruct narratives about gender nonconformity by emphasizing the individual's choice to embrace their identity, ignoring societal pressures to conform to traditional gender roles, and often sensationalizing the transition process through language that is both misleading and disrespectful. The media tends to focus on the physical aspects of one's appearance rather than the internal struggles faced during this process.